Balance Scorecard Implementation Challenges in Institution of Higher Learning: Overview of Prior Studies

  • Peter U. Anuforo Department of Accounting, University of Maiduguri Nigeria, Nigeria
  • Hazeline Ayoup Tunku Puteri Intan Safinaz School of Accountancy (TISSA-UUM), College of Business, Universiti Utara Malaysia, 06010 UUM Sintok, Kedah, Malaysia
  • Nasiru Saidu Department of Business Administration, Bauchi State University Gadau, Nigeria
Keywords: Balance scorecard, Malaysia Public Institution of Higher Learning, Performance Management, Strategy Alignment, Strategy Map.

Abstract

The incessant decline in the performance of Malaysian public institution of higher learning since 2007 to date has brought to fore the question of its performance management process. Studies have shown that performance management is a general phenomenon in the institution of higher learning worldwide. The implementation issues of Balance scorecard (BSC) is more pronounced in the non-profit outfit and governmental organizations (NPGOs) compared to the profit-oriented outfit. Reasons being that the BSC was originally developed and (or) meant for the profit-oriented outfit and not exactly the other way round. The purpose of this paper is to provide insight into the issues of performance management in the institution of higher learning and specifically regarding the implementation issues of BSC encountered among Malaysia public institution of higher learning. This study provides a review of previous literature on the BSC implementation issues. Several implementation issues identified from the literatures are strategy misalignment, strategy communication issues, manager’s acceptance/employees buy-in, the issue of clarity of vision, mission, strategy, and outcome, and strategy map implementation issues. Findings revealed that the implementation issues of the BSC among Malaysia public institution actually helps to unravel the pitfalls of BSC project and provides a roadmap show that can improve and sustain effective performance management. The implication of this study is aimed at providing the means by which the Malaysian public institution of higher learning can identify the issues inherent in BSC implementation or strategy implementation and the way forward.

 

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Aaltonen, P., &Ikävalko, H. (2002).Implementing strategies successfully.Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 13(6), 415-418.
Ahn, H. (2001). Applying the balanced scorecard concept: an experience report.Long range planning, 34(4), 441-461.
Alexander, L. D. (1985). Successfully implementing strategic decisions.Long range planning, 18(3), 91-97.
Al-Zwyalif, I. M. (2012). The possibility of implementing balanced scorecard in Jordanian private universities. International Business Research, 5(11), 113.
Anjomshoae, A., Hassan, A., Kunz, N., Wong, K. Y., & de Leeuw, S. (2017). Toward a dynamic balanced scorecard model for humanitarian relief organizations’ performance management.Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management, 7(2), 194-218.
Atkinson, H. (2006). Strategy implementation: a role for the balanced scorecard? Management Decision, 44(10), 1441-1460.
Ayoup, H. (2009). Observational Assessment of the Balanced Scorecard Strategic Alignment Process: A Study of a Utility Company.
Ayoup, H., Omar, N. H., & Rahman, I. K. A. (2010, December). Strategy maps as a communication tool in Balanced Scorecard implementation: Study of a Malaysian utility company. In Science and Social Research (CSSR), 2010 International Conference on (pp. 48-52). IEEE.
Ayoup, H., Omar, N., & Rahman, I. K. A. (2015a).Behavioural Factors Affecting Strategic Alignment Based on the Balanced Scorecard Framework: Evidence from A Malaysian Company.
Ayoup, H., Omar, N., & Rahman, I. K. A. (2016). Balanced scorecard and strategic alignment: A Malaysian case. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 6(4S).
Ayoup, H., Omar, N., & Rahman, I. K. A. (2015b). Managing strategic alignment using the balanced scorecard: A Malaysian Company’s experience.
Azizan, H. (2007).Ready for the big leap.The Star Newspaper. 18 November, http://thestar.com.my/news/story,asp?file=/2007/11/1/8/education/19484775&sec=education
Beer, M., &Eisenstat, R. A. (2000).The silent killers of strategy implementation and learning.Sloan management review, 41(4), 29.
Bergeron, F., Raymond, L. &Rivard, S. (2003). Ideal patterns of strategic alignment and business performance.Information & Management, 41, 1003-1020.
Bergeron, F., Raymond, L., &Rivard, S. (2004). Ideal patterns of strategic alignment and business performance.Information & management, 41(8), 1003-1020.
Binden, W., Mziu, H., &Suhaimi, M. A. (2014).Employing the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) to Measure Performance in Higher Education–Malaysia.International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Research, 4(1).
Braam, G. J., &Nijssen, E. J. (2004). Performance effects of using the balanced scorecard: a note on the Dutch experience. Long range planning, 37(4), 335-349.
Cândido, C. J., & Santos, S. P. (2015). Strategy implementation: What is the failure rate?.Journal of Management & Organization, 21(2), 237-262.
Cano, J. A., Vergara, J. J., &Puerta, F. A. (2017). Design and implementation of a balanced scorecard in a colombian company. RevistaEspacios, 38(31).
Chan, Y. C. L. (2004). Performance Measurement and Adoption of Balanced Scorecards: A Survey of Municipal Governments in the USA and Canada, The International Journal of Public Sector Management, 17, 3: 204-221.
Chimtengo, S., Mkandawire, K., &Hanif, R. (2017).An evaluation of performance using the balanced scorecard model for the University of Malawi's Polytechnic.African Journal of Business Management, 11(4), 84.
DaneshAsgari, S., Haeri, A., &Jafari, M. (2017).Integration of Balanced Scorecard and Three-stage Data Envelopment Analysis Approaches.Iranian Journal of Management Studies, 10(2), 527-550.
Davis, S. & Albright, T. (2004). An Investigation of the Effect of Balanced Scorecard Implementation on Financial Performance, Management Accounting Research, 15: 135-153.
Decoene, V., Bruggeman, W. (2006), Strategic alignment and middle-level managers’ motivation in a balanced score.International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 26(3-4), 429-448.
DeWaal, A.A. &Coevert, V. (2007). The Effect of Performance Management on the Organizational Results of a Bank, International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 56, 5/6: 397- 416.
Dimitropoulos, P., Kosmas, I., &Douvis, I. (2017).Implementing the balanced scorecard in a local government sport organization: Evidence from Greece.International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 66(3), 362-379.
Evans, N. (2005). Assessing the Balanced Scorecard as a Management Tool for Hotels, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management Accounting, 17, 5: 376-390.
Fernandes, K. J., Raja, V., &Whalley, A. (2006).Lessons from implementing the balanced scorecard in a small and medium size manufacturing organization.Technovation, 26(5-6), 623-634.
Ferreira, A. M. S. C. (2017). How managers use the balanced scorecard to support strategy implementation and formulation processes. Tékhne-Review of Applied Management Studies, (1), 2-15.
Gamal, A., &Soemantri, A. I. (2017).The Effect of Balanced Scorecard on the Private College Performance (Case Study at the University of WR Supratman Surabaya).Archives of Business Research, 5(5).
Hladchenko, M. (2015).Balanced Scorecard–a strategic management system of the higher education institution.International Journal of Educational Management, 29(2), 167-176.Hoboken NJ: John Wiley & Sons Inc.
Hoque, Z., James, W. (2000), Linking balanced scorecard measures to size and market factors: Impact on organizational performance. Journal of Management Accounting Research, 12, 1-17.
Hu, B., Leopold-Wildburger, U., &Strohhecker, J. (2017). Strategy map concepts in a balanced scorecard cockpit improve performance. European Journal of Operational Research, 258(2), 664-676.
Ittner, C. D., Larcker, D. F., & Meyer, M. W. (1997).Performance, compensation, and the Balanced Scorecard.Unpublished, Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, 1.
Ittner, C. D., Larcker, D. F., & Randall, T. (2003a).Performance implications of strategic performance measurement in financial services firms.Accounting, organizations and society, 28(7-8), 715-741.
Ittner, C.D. &Larcker, D.F. (2003b), “Coming up short on non-financial performance Measurement”, Harvard Business Review, Vol. 81 No. 11, pp. 88-95.
Kaplan R.S. & Norton D.P. (1992): The Balanced Scorecard - Measures that drive performance. Harvard Business Review, 70.1: 71-79.
Kaplan R.S. and Norton D.P. (1996): The Balanced Scorecard. Translating Strategy into Action.Mcgraw-Hill, Boston, MA.
Kaplan R.S. and Norton D.P. (2004): Strategy Maps: Converting Intangible Assets into Tangible Outcomes. Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA.
Kaplan, A. M., &Haenlein, M. (2010). Users of the world, unite! The challenges and opportunities of Social Media.Business horizons, 53(1), 59-68.
Kaplan, R. and Norton, D. (2001), “Transforming the balanced scorecard from performance measurement to strategic management: part I”, Accounting Horizons, Vol. 15 No. 1, pp. 87-104.
Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (2006a). Alignment: Using the Balanced Scorecard to Create Corporate Synergies (Vol. 1). Boston Massachusetts: Harvard Business School Press.
Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (2006b). How to implement a new strategy without disrupting your organization.Harvard business review, 84(3), 100.
Kaplan, R. S., Norton, D. P., & Barrows, E. A. (2008).Developing the strategy: Vision, value gaps, and analysis.Balanced scorecard report, 10(1), 1-5.
Karpagam, U. P., &Suganthi, L. (2012).A strategy map of balanced scorecard in academic institutions for performance improvement.IUP Journal of Business Strategy, 9(3), 7.
Kathuria, R., Joshi, M. P., &Porth, S. J. (2007). Organizational alignment and performance: past, present and future. Management Decision, 45(3), 503-517.
Keating, M., & Harrington, D. (2003).The challenges of implementing quality in the Irish hotel industry.Journal of European Industrial Training, 27(9), 441-453.
Khomba, J. K., Vermaak, F. N., &Hanif, R. (2012). Relevance of the balanced scorecard model in Africa: Shareholder-centred or stakeholder-centred?.African Journal of Business Management, 6(17), 5773.
Kim, J., Suh, E., & Hwang, H. (2003).A model for evaluating the effectiveness of CRM using the balanced scorecard.Journal of interactive Marketing, 17(2), 5-19.
Kwak, Y. H., &Anbari, F. T. (2006). Benefits, obstacles, and future of six sigma approach. Technovation, 26(5-6), 708-715.
Lau, C.M. and Sholihin, M. (2005), “Financial and non-financial performance measures: how do they affect job satisfaction?”,British Accounting Review, Vol. 37 No. 4, pp. 389-413.
Lee N (2006). Measuring the performance of public sector organisations: A case study on Public Schools in Malaysia.Measuring Business Excellence 10(4):50-64.
MacPhail, A., &Halbert, J. (2005). The implementation of a revised physical education syllabus in Ireland: circumstances, rewards and costs. European Physical Education Review, 11(3), 287-308.
Madsen, D. Ø.,&Stenheim, T. (2014). Perceived problems associated with the implementation of the balanced scorecard: evidence from Scandinavia.
Maiga, A. S., & Jacobs, F. A. (2003). Balanced scorecard, activity based costing and company performance: an empirical analysis. Journal of Management Issues, 15(3), 283-301.
Malina, M. A., &Selto, F. H. (2001). Communicating and controlling strategy: an empirical study of the effectiveness of the balanced scorecard. Journal of management accounting research, 13(1), 47-90.
Mankins, M. C., & Steele, R. (2005).Turning great strategy into great performance.Harvard business review, 2607.
Marr, B., &Schiuma, G. (2003).Business performance measurement – past, present and future.Management decision, 41(8), 680–687.doi:10.1108/00251740310496198
Martello, M., Watson, J. and Fischer, M. (2008), Implementing a Balanced Scorecard in a Not-for-profit Organization, Journal of Business and Economics Research, 6(9), pp.67-80.
Martello, M., Watson, J. G., & Fischer, M. J. (2016).Implementing a balanced scorecard in a not-for-profit organization.Journal of Business & Economics Research (Online), 14(3), 61.
Mayer, R. C., & Gavin, M. B. (2005). Trust in management and performance: who minds the shop while the employees watch the boss? Academy of Management Journal, 48(5), 874-888.
McPhail, R., Herington, C., &Guilding, C. (2008).Human resource managers’ perceptions of the applications and merit of the balanced scorecard in hotels. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 27(4), 623-631.
Melnyk, S.A., Calantone, R.J., Luft, J., Stewart, D.M., &Zsidisin, G.A. (2005).An empirical investigation of the metrics alignment process.International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 54(5/6), 312-324.
Merchant, K. A. (1987). How and why firms disregard the controllability principle. Accounting and management: Field study perspectives, 316-338.
Mithas, S., Tafti, A., & Mitchell, W. (2013). How a firm’s competitive environment and digital strategic posture influence digital business strategy. Mis Quarterly, 37(2), 511-536.
Modell, S. (2012), The politics of the balanced scorecard. Journal of Accounting and Organizational Change, 8(4), 475-489.
Mohamed, M. (2007). Plan to shape varsities of world class. The Star Newspaper, 14 November. http://thestar.com.my/news/story .asp?file=/2007/ 11/1 4/nation/ 1 9464095&se
Moore, M. H. (2003). The Public Value Scorecard: A Rejoinder and an Alternative to Strategic Performance Measurement and Management in Non-Profit Organization by Robert Kaplan, Social Science Research Network Electronic Paper Collection, Retrieved from http://ssrn.com/ abstract=402880
Nadler, D.A.,&Tushman, M.L. (1997). Competing by Design: The Power of Organizational Architecture.New York: Oxford University Press.
Neely, A., Adams, C., & Crowe, P. (2001).The performance prism in practice.Measuring business excellence, 5(2), 6-13.
Niven, P.R. (2008). Balanced Scorecard Step-by-Step for Government and Nonprofit Agencies,organizational performance in the hotel sector.Tourism Management 26 (5),690-702.
Northcott, D. &Taulapapa, T.M. (2012), “Using the balanced scorecard to manage performance in public sector organizations: issues and challenges”, International Journal of Public Sector Management, Vol. 25 No. 3, pp. 166-191.
Othman, R. (2006). Balanced scorecard and causal model development: preliminary findings. Management Decision, 44(5), 690-702.
Othman, R. (2008). Enhancing the effectiveness of the balanced scorecard with scenario planning.International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 57(3), 259-266.
Pandey, I. M. (2005). Balanced scorecard: myth and reality. Vikalpa,30(1), 51-66.
Papalexandris, A., Ioannou, G., &Prastacos, G. P. (2004).Implementing the balanced scorecard in Greece: a software firm’s experience.Long Range Planning, 37(4), 351-366.
Park, S., Lee, H., &Chae, S. W. (2017). Rethinking balanced scorecard (BSC) measures: formative versus reflective measurement models. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 66(1), 92-110.
Philbin, S. P. (2011). Design and implementation of the Balanced Scorecard at a university institute. Measuring Business Excellence, 15(3), 34-45.
Pietrzak, M., Paliszkiewicz, J., &Klepacki, B. (2015).The application of the balanced scorecard (BSC) in the higher education setting of a Polish university.Online Journal of Applied Knowledge Management, 3(1), 151-164.
Pongatichat, P., Johnston, R. (2008), Exploring strategy-misaligned performance measurement.International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 57(3), 207-222.Press, Boston, MA.
Praptapa, A., &Yahya, M. A. B. The Use of Balance Scorecard for Performance Control: Case of Water Supply Company in Indonesia.
Ramachandran, S., & Foo, H. (2007). Public universities fail outstanding test. New Straits Times, 6.
Richard, R.Y.Y., Yang, B., Lien, B.Y., McLean, G.N. &Kuo, Y. (2009). Dynamic Capability: Impact of process alignment and organizational learning culture on performance. Journal of World Business, 401,1-10.
Richardson, S. (2004). The key elements of Balanced Scorecard success.Ivey Business Journal, 69(2), 7-9.
Rigby, D., &Bilodeau, B. (2007).Management tools & trends. Bain & Company.Available at: http://www.bain.com/management_tools/home.asp.
Roest, P. (1997). The golden rules for implementing the balanced business scorecard.Information Management & Computer Security, 5(5), 163-165.
Schaap, J. I. (2012). Strategy implementations-can organizations attain outstanding performance. Strategic Management Review, 6(1), 98-121.
Schneiderman, A. M. (2001). How to Build a Balanced Scorecard, part 3: Selecting Scorecard Metrics.
Shukri, N. F. M., &Ramli, A. (2015). Organizational structure and performances of responsible Malaysian healthcare providers: A balanced scorecard perspective. Procedia Economics and Finance, 28, 202-212.
Skinner, W. (1969).Manufacturing- Missing Link in Corporate Strategy.Harvard Business Review, May- June, 1-10.
Slavica, T., Ljubica, K., &Jelena, J. (2017).The modern concept of measuring efficiency-Implementation and attitudes of BSC.TEM JOURNAL-TECHNOLOGY EDUCATION MANAGEMENT INFORMATICS, 6(3), 525-533.
Speckbacher, G., Bischof, J., & Pfeiffer, T. (2003).A descriptive analysis on the implementation of balanced scorecards in German-speaking countries.Management accounting research, 14(4), 361-388.
Sterling, J. (2003). Translating strategy into effective implementation: dispelling the myths and highlighting what works. Strategy & Leadership, 31(3), 27-34.
Taylor, J., & Baines, C. (2012). Performance management in UK universities: implementing the Balanced Scorecard. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 34(2), 111-124.
Trahant, B. (2008). Six communication secrets of top-performing organizations.Public manager, 37(3), 68.
Turco, M. (2017). Development Perspective of Balance Scorecard through “multi-dimensional” value measurement. GSTF Journal on Business Review (GBR), 3(3).
Umashev, C., & Willett, R. (2008). Challenges to implementing strategic performance measurement systems in multi‐objective organizations: the case of a large local government authority. Abacus, 44(4), 377-398.
Vaidyanathan, S. (2005), Enterprise architecture in the context of organizational strategy.BPTrends, 9, 1-9
Yu, M. L., Hamid, S., Ijab, M. T., & Soo, H. P. (2009). The e-balanced scorecard (e-BSC) for measuring academic staff performance excellence.Higher Education, 57(6), 813-828.
Zhijun, L. I. N., Y. U. Zengbiao, and Liqun Zhang."Performance outcomes of balanced scorecard application in hospital administration in China."China Economic Review 30 (2014): 1-15.
Published
2018-06-08
How to Cite
Anuforo, P. U., Ayoup, H., & Saidu, N. (2018). Balance Scorecard Implementation Challenges in Institution of Higher Learning: Overview of Prior Studies. American International Journal of Social Science Research, 2(2), 1-11. Retrieved from https://www.cribfb.com/journal/index.php/aijssr/article/view/173
Section
Articles